June-July Market Observations
July 2nd, 2009Late June Real Estate Market Observations: (within is a discussion of ”Defining a Good Deal”!)
The real estate markets appear to be slowly normalizing, but it still is a strong buyers market with the elements of “The Perfect Rainbow” (a previous blog,) still very much prevailing. It surely must be an historic “Good Time to Buy” period! The national and local news media continue to report higher numbers of transactions, and we’re certainly noticing that locally. Prices too are stabilizing, especially on the better options, and foreclosures are way down, especially locally.
So those factors in “The Perfect Rainbow”….
Great inventory from which to choose
- Still-incredible interest rates, but appearing anxious to rise
- Modest competition, but there’s more all the time!
- An “affordability index” at an all-time high
- A phenomenal $8,000 tax credit available for many of you – (“first time” buyers.)
(there’s a separate blog on this subject.)
We’ve mentioned many times that the good local markets in Metro East never ever were as “bad” as many parts of the U. S., and that’s a firmly-held observation. The correlation is that the “bubble” was never as large as those “other parts”. And we would like to claim an influence borne of careful buying, but we have yet to hear from a single former client that they’re enduring foreclosure.
And so market improvements appear to be real, and that comforts everyone. We still think it takes careful attention to the principles of buying wisely, and of course, we’re prepared to help with that.
And on the subject of “buying wisely”, we’re observing an emerging market condition that could stand discussion. It can make a difference to present and future buyers….is important for them, and us to understand.
It’s a fact of this current market that the price-spread between high quality properties and lower quality, (because of condition and location, mostly,) is much, much higher than that which had been considered normal. As we’ve discussed it in our offices, it’s really not hard to understand, but there’s a consequential buying lesson here, too…and a classic buyer’s trap.
Buyers are simply being more discriminating, more careful in their comparisons. And they are NOT taking on properties of lesser quality when they have better options. And that “quality” relates to both the livability of the home as well as their resaleability, the latter often otherwise overlooked.
In the slam-bang years, buyers were overlooking more faults, but they aren’t nowadays, especially with our help and direction…for we are augmenting that critical focus if not insisting on it…and in fact, we always have.
But we also believe these “lessons” will be well-learned, and will become a part of our home buying culture for perhaps years to come…home buyers will be more critical. And the spread of values (prices) between good and poor properties will remain larger. And that means we need to prepare for these future buyers when we buy now. And that’s good for the whole principle of “wiser homebuying”.
This of course challenges the classic definition of a “Good Deal”. We’ve always advocated that the quest for discounts alone was not necessarily part of the “Good Deal”. In fact, I’d like to quote here from our long-standing principle defined in “Wiser Homebuying”. Everything in this article from here to the end was written years ago and quoted word for word, but it still is truth, only reinforced by the current markets. It includes the reference to the “traps”.
This if from “Buying Goals, the Quest for Discounts vs. Picking Cherries” “But most important: The quest for discounts in our opinion, is not the most important buying goal…that one is setting up the best resale possible (see the next page). Worse, looking for discounts can often be competitive and even distracting. Read on!
B. Picking “Cherries” There’s only one hard number that appraisers and realtors work with in evaluating homes….and that’s price per square foot. In any category, homes are actually priced all over the place….above and below that average. Homes above the average (we call them “cherries”) are there because of superior upgrades, location, setting, site, location, maintenance….many things. Homes below the average are there because they don’t have these features.
We strongly believe our buying goal should be to “pick cherries”…..pick the best home we can find in the category, with superior upgrades, location, setting, site, location, and maintenance, with resale all set up. To begin with, the “system” has already drawn the price of that home down to the average when pricing was defined. The seller may still believe it’s worth more, hence carries strong reluctance to lower it anyway. But if he gets a lot of interest in the home, and multiple offers, that resistance turns to cement. On the other hand, homes actually below the norm (lacking all those good qualities) could easily be priced higher than they deserve; they’re drawn to the average, too, and their owners will support that pricing direction. But if it doesn’t sell as quickly as he wants, or if he gets no action, and especially if he’s in a hurry, you may catch him at a time where he’ll consider a substantial discount. You know what? Big deal! Even with a discount, it could still be a bad deal, especially if has one of those incurable diseases such as a bad location, a miserable floor plan, or any number of things. The real points: Discounts are rare in “cherries”.
Discounts and “cherries” are usually incompatible goals. Discounts are largely not under our control. Picking cherries is much more under our control (with your concurrence and teamwork). In fact, the quest for discounts, without balance, is a dangerous quest! It’s almost classic misdirection, away from a longer term but more valid objective, to a get-it-now one. The latter is okay when buying a truck, which is inevitably going to depreciate the minute you drive it off the lot. But homes appreciate, and that’s a totally different game. That makes it an investment, and worthy of a totally different set of standards. A quest for “Cherries”, at a fair price, is a much more valid and enduring goal.
It’s no sin to pay a fair price for the perfect home, with resale set up. It’s a serious sin to pay too much for a disadvantaged home… even if you get a discount! Any small discount you might leave on the table in an effort to button up the purchase of the home is inconsequential in the long run…consider it the hedge against the risk of losing the home in the first place. And the following is taken from our piece; “Mistakes That Buyers Make”
3. Approaching negotiations like you’re buying a truck. The pitfall here is that you cannot let the short term quest for discounts cloud the much more important long term quest for appreciation, expanded in a previous section. Remember the two big differences. A home is an investment, a truck is not. There are many trucks you could buy, but there could be just one home that’s appropriate. A home is a long term investment that should appreciate in value….like buying a growth stock. A truck depreciates when you drive it off the lot….so it’s 1st cost is a much bigger issue. (To continue the analogy, if we consider the purchase of a home to be a purchase of a growth stock….then its livability is the “dividend” you might hope for during the holding period. And that’s what were trying to do….long term and short term benefits; growth and dividends!) End of Quotations: We hope this helps explain the phenomenon we’re seeing about price spreads, and helps set up a healthier buying attitude….we believe it to be a profound truth. Of course we’ll talk about it openly when we see you. Merrill Ottwein